When Public Schools Aren’t Created Equally From Inside

The school year is coming to a close, as you see the delight in children’s eyes with visions of no homework, sleeping in, endless cartoons or hours spent playing outside and the many teacher videos popping up all over social media where they are celebrating the end of another challenging year with dance routines and song.

The other sign of a school year wrapping up are career fairs. The idea behind this event is to find teachers not only locally, but from all over the world to fill vacancies that have either become available because of transitions or positions they were not able to fill through-out the year.

Photo Credit: Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools Facebook
Photo Credit: Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools Facebook

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools (CMS) held such a fair on May 21, 2016 to fill over 400 vacancies including instructional (teachers, social workers, counselors, etc.) and non-instructional (janitorial services, ASEP, teachers aide, landscaping, etc.) CMS has held this type of fair for many years due to teacher shortages and teachers leaving to travel about 20-30 minutes to South Carolina , where teachers’ pay scales are higher per year with perks of pay raises and money to buy school supplies. (Yes, I know you are thinking, shouldn’t that be a given? Ask any teacher you know and they will tell you it is not.) North Carolina Governor Pat McCrory signed a new bill into law in 2014 however, the bill left most disenchanted due to the new salary scale, which left most veteran teachers not seeing much benefit.

I have lived in Charlotte for many years, I witnessed the exodus. I saw more teachers leaving, positions unable to be filled and can recall times my daughter had 39 other classmates in class with her. Yes, 40 children in one class with ONE teacher.

Now, let me get back to the career fair. I have a friend who had dreamed of perhaps being a teacher. He has the education and personality that would benefit children and I informed him of the fair. He excitedly filled out the application, contacted whom he thought he needed to at Charlotte Mecklenburg School’s offices and even attended a seminar about the upcoming fair, so that he would perhaps have a better footing on learning who and what CMS was looking for. He did say the presenter of the webinar did not “present”, so the information was limited because she spent most of the webinar answering questions during the time not allotted for questions. Nonetheless, he remained excited about the upcoming fair.

Photo Credit: personal
Photo Credit: personal

Career day comes and he is “suited and booted” ready to go and meet teachers and administrators from CMS schools with the idea, that face to face time is important in not only getting your questions answered, but also attempting to see who he may be working for. Not to mention, the career fair advertisement stated that attendees could be hired that day. What? Hired on the same day!? What prospect who was excited to begin a career fair would not be pumped about the possibility?

He arrives at the Park Expo and Conference Center at the time stated he should be there and there is a line. Okay, no problem. There are of course, a lot of people there and a line is expected. However, he stood in this line for over an hour because for some reason, CMS decided to have people wait outside as they attempted to direct attendees to certain “specialties” and label them as such before they could get in the door. These specialties  were based on your transcripts. Which was a tab bit backwards considering prior to the career fair, applicants were already separated based on teacher license and lateral entry. I would think incorporating that step would lessen wait times and confusion. But, alas that turned out not to be the case. My friend saw people getting turned away and even an attendee who currently worked for CMS and was looking to get into an instructional position. This didn’t make not even a tiny bit of sense to me. She already works for you, why did she need to stand in line? But, I digress.

Photo Credit: personal
Photo Credit: personal

Finally, my friend makes it into the fair after his “specialty” being deemed as Marketing, even though he was there for Computer Science and IT positions. I spoke to him after he exits asking how things went. He told me about how one of the administrators at a West Charlotte school stating they were trying to change the image/reputation of the school and he looked as of he would be a good candidate. He also spoke about another school and their plans. All exciting developments for him because he would be a first year teacher having never taught before. I was excited for him and I was not even there. But, then he mentioned something that changed my spirit. He stated he could immediately tell which schools had bigger budgets and staff that were truly excited about being there.

While all the schools at the career fair (160 of them to be exact) had signs above their tables stating who they were, some schools had professionally made banners, school crest, office supplies and tablets displaying websites and videos about the schools. Then there were schools who had poorly hand-made signs, no supplies and staff who seemed as if they would have loved to be anywhere else but there. And this is what saddened me.

Understandably, a school may not have the most enthusiastic staff members 24/7. Humans are allowed to have off days and are most definitely allowed mistakes. But, not at a school career fair, where hundreds or even thousands of potential teachers are there to give you everything they have. What type of potential teacher are you going to attract if your current teachers are sitting at a table representing you with the appearance of not being happy about being one of your current teachers?

Twin pics
Photo Credit: CMS Jobs Facebook Page

It is known not all schools are created equal, even with all the fluff we hear on television and the cotton candy nice statements we hear amongst school administrators. However, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools need to tell me why they would not even level the playing field (if you will) at their OWN career fair and make sure all of the schools present had the exact same appearance outside of school colors and mascots? Why would you all not make sure all of your schools had at the very least, pencils, pens, sticky notes, cups, banners? You know, those things the school system’s budget could handle without breaking the supposed bank. By allowing the schools to pretty much fend for themselves, you set into motion detrimental perceptions, that may or may not be true.

If you have first teachers or even veteran teachers walking through a massive expo looking for their dream job, there would undoubtedly be two reactions (1) teachers who want to teach, period and no school is above or below their reach or (2) teachers who will look at handmade signs and a ill-fitting table-cloth and shy away from those schools because they give off the impression (whether right or wrong) that those schools have no support and they will have to pay for supplies themselves. And could you really blame a teacher for falling into the second category? Come on, most teachers are not making huge salaries and simply cannot afford to pay for their own supplies.

There is something definitely wrong, when a school system such as Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools did not understand the absolute need for unity at this career fair. Schools need united fronts no matter the economic or demographic background of its students and community and if the top administrators of CMS do not realize this, where are we as a first-class city? There has been an issue with segregation in the school system for years and the School Choice program has done nothing to combat this issue. Even if a parent desired for their child to go to a better school, they were hit with hurdles with those schools being blocked before the choice application process even begun.

Still From The WBTV website
Photo Credit: WBTV website

Anyone walking into that expo for the very first or fifteenth time should not be able to tell where a school is located, their community involvement nor their financial viability. There is a terrible narrative out there, where people believe that a school in a economically challenged community does not have administrators, students and parents who care. This career fair added “points” to that troubling misnomer. We are killing some of these schools from the inside and not giving them a fighting chance.

My friend flew into Charlotte just for this career fair from Washington, D.C. and CMS, this is the impression you left him with to take back home. When I did research for this article, I placed the hashtag they wanted everyone to use while attending and I came across someone on Twitter, who stated  he has a Bachelors and Master’s Degree and was recommended to apply for a custodial position to get in the door, CMS that is the impression you left on a Charlottean.

Photo Credit" Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools Facebook
Photo Credit” Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools Facebook

I would love to hear from Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools on their concept for this career fair and why they made some of their decisions. Somehow, I do not think that will happen.


9 thoughts on “When Public Schools Aren’t Created Equally From Inside”

  1. Thank you for sharing this! Very timely! I’m considering a move back to Charlotte and noticed the rating of the elementary school my daughter (now 18) attended. Very concerning since I need to be mindful of that for my 9yr old. I spent this weekend slightly puzzled as I tried to understand exactly what’s going on with CMS.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for reading Kristina. The most disheartened thing about my article is that I hated to write it because #CMS is actually one of the best public school districts that I have come across and my daughter received a stellar education from them. (She is graduating this year.) Nonetheless, they do have some real issues that have to be discussed in a real and honest way. The career fair from the perspective of someone who knows nothing about CMS was dismal and I could not believe they didn’t make sure all of their OWN schools were given equal footing. My daughter attended South Charlotte Middle School and even though it was aggressive with academics, she was able to excel once she went to high school because of that aggressive…the principal retired right before her last year and the school changed dramatically. I wouldn’t cross The Queen City off your list just yet, as I do love the city. However, I would pay close attention to the changes that are in the works. A lot has been brewing here. Thank you again.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Kim, I shared your, “Say what now?” reaction when I read this gentlemen’s tweet enough to actually respond to him to see what his experience was about. He was so gracious, stating that it only gave him motivation to keep trying. However, he wondered how he could show people what he could do if he doesn’t even get a chance. #CMS’ whole lay-out for that career fair was completely off. How IT ends up in Marketing and how a masters degree holder would have to apply for a janitorial position to get into the door. Was lateral entry not even an option for him? I’m “underwhelmed” by Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools right now. Thank you for taking the time to read my article.


  2. How disappointing. I cannot understand how a Masters degree would qualify for custodial, why a current employee would need to stand in line and the list goes on. If you’re miserable, quit! I’ve been saying this a lot lately. I said it on Sunday about the bagger at Publix. If you hate your job that much that you have to pass negativity onto others – please quit.


  3. Wom! This makes no sense to me. It seems like CMS needs to do some reevaluating asap to avoid this from happening in the future.


  4. Thanks for this! I can go on and on about the extreme lack in so many of our school systems. It’s pretty doggone horrible! We definitely need smaller class sizes and more passionate teachers.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s